Why are we losing women from the industry?
We all thought we were doing better. We’re not. Cathryn Greville on where we’re really losing women.
We all thought we were doing better. Ask most people in our industry whether things have improved for women over the past twenty years and they’ll say yes. Look around. There are more women in graduate intakes, more women on industry panels, more women leading projects and running firms. It feels like progress.
The numbers say otherwise. In 2006, women made up 17% of the building, construction and infrastructure workforce. Today it’s 12.4%. In the trades, it’s 3.4%.
When Cathryn Greville, CEO of NAWIC (the National Association of Women in Construction), shared those figures on the podcast, our host’s reaction was the same as most of ours would be: surely we’re improving? Cathryn didn’t soften it.
“Yes, they’ve changed, but actually we’ve gone down. We were sitting at seventeen percent in two thousand and six.”
Cathryn Greville, NAWIC
It’s not that we can’t attract them
It’s tempting to read that as a trades problem, and the trades numbers are stark: of the women who start a trade apprenticeship, 72% have left by the end of their first year. But the same pattern shows up in our architecture and engineering practices. Graduate intakes in many disciplines are close to even. Look at associate and director level, and the women thin out.
The usual answer is attraction: more school visits, more campaigns, more scholarships. All of that matters. Cathryn’s point is that it isn’t where we’re falling down.
“We’re able to attract those people into the sector, but we’re not able to keep them.”
Cathryn Greville, NAWIC
Most leaders would nod along to that. The real question is whether we know where, in our own firms, we’re losing them.
Where it happens
NAWIC’s research with the University of Sydney found that the single biggest risk point for losing women mid-career is pregnancy. Not because women stop wanting their careers, but because many workplaces aren’t set up for the moment someone says, “I’m pregnant.”
Cathryn describes women who are the first person in their team, or on their site, to take parental leave. They’re working it out with managers who have never done it before and haven’t been trained for it. Some are quietly moved into admin roles they never asked for. On some sites, even equitable toilets are still missing.
She’s clear that policy alone doesn’t fix it. You can have the best parental leave policy in the country, but unless the direct manager and the team understand it, believe in it and know how to use it, it doesn’t make for a good experience.
Why it matters more now
We have billions of dollars of work in the pipeline, housing targets in every state and the Olympics coming to Queensland. Every architecture and engineering firm is short of experienced people. When a senior woman leaves after her first baby, we don’t just lose a person. We lose ten or fifteen years of client relationships, project knowledge and the example she sets for the women coming up behind her.
How we can get better at this
It starts with a conversation. Cathryn hears from plenty of managers who panic when someone announces a pregnancy: who’ll cover the role, what duties need to change, how long they’ll be away. Her first question back is always the same: have you spoken to them? Every person, every pregnancy and every family is different. Asking first, and checking in as things change, solves more than any template.
It helps to prepare our managers for that moment before it arrives. Most people only face it a handful of times in their career, and the first response sticks with the person on the other side. A little training goes a long way here, for the parental leave conversation and for the harder ones too.
We can look at how the work is set up, not just the policy. Few daycares open at 6am, and no schools do. Cathryn points to John Holland, which split site teams into early and late start groups, so people could do drop-offs or pick-ups and still do a full day. Simple changes like that make it possible to stay.
We can make parental leave a parenting conversation rather than a gender one, and make it normal for dads to take it and to work flexibly afterwards.
We can look at who we’re backing. Cathryn draws a clear line between mentoring, which shares advice, and sponsorship, which means “actively speaking a woman’s name when she’s not in the room.” Our industry still tends to promote people who look like us. When NAWIC opened its sponsorship pilot, more senior men signed up to sponsor than women signed up to be sponsored. Men want to help. Many just need to know how.
We can also ask the people who leave, and the people who stay, what’s getting in the way. The answers are usually already there. We just haven’t asked.
Everyone has a role
Cathryn’s message to the industry is that retention is where the real change will happen, and that everyone has a part to play, not just leaders and not just women. NAWIC has been doing this work for 30 years, and the reasons women leave are well known.
Maybe the more useful question for each of us isn’t whether things have got better. It’s whether the next person in our team to say “I’m pregnant” will want to come back.
Related reading: Do our people want more than profit?
Want to talk this through with peers? Our HR & People and Owners & Practice Leaders industry groups meet regularly. Find your group.
